Judge Finds Lyrics and Themes “Guns, Money, and Jewelry” Too Commonplace for Copyright Protection

An Illinois judge rejected an infringement claim brought by rapper Gutta, alleging that a song released by hip-hop artist Future infringed his rights. Scott Hervey and Jamie Lincenberg talk about this dispute on this episode of The Briefing. Watch this episode on the Weintraub YouTube channel here.   Show Notes: Jamie: On August 25, 2023, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois rejected an infringement claim brought by rapper Dequan Robinson, otherwise known as Gutta, alleging that a song released by hip-hop artist Future infringed his rights. We are going to talk about this case and why the court dismissed Robinson's claim on today's episode of The Briefing I'm Jamie Lincenberg of Weintraub Tobin and I'm joined today by my colleague Scott Hervey. Scott: Hi Jamie, thanks for having me today. Looking forward to diving into this case. So first, why don't you provide us with a quick recap on the lawsuit. Jamie: So, on Friday, a Chicago federal court dismissed the copyright infringement lawsuit that was brought in 2021 against popular Atlanta hip hop artist Future by Virginia rapper Dequan Robinson, who, as I said, performs as Gutta. He alleged that Future's song, ‘When I Think About It’, released in 2018, ripped off his own 2017 song ‘When You Think About It’ to make a hit of his own and claiming that he had emailed a draft of his song to future's producer a year before the song was released. His complaint alleged that they created the song in the image of his song, likening his case to the famous Blurred Lines lawsuit in which Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke's very popular track Blurred Lines was found to have infringed Marvin Gaye's iconic ‘Got to Give It Up.’ The lawsuit raised arguments that the works were substantially similar due to the following factors one, similar thematic content of guns, money and jewelry two, that they were both in the key of e and three, that they had the same chorus and verse structure. The lawsuit also named some of future's companies, his producer and Sony Music Entertainment as defendants. The suit sought injunctive relief damages, a running royalty and litigation costs, among other relief. Scott: Future’s team filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that Robinson did not adequately allege the protectable elements of ‘When You Think About It’ were copied. They argued that both the songs repeat exceedingly commonplace phrases when you think about It and when I think about it, and both include commonplace themes of guns, money and jewelry. Jamie: That's right. Then Robinson's team filed an opposition to the motion, citing that there are a lot of questionable similarities between the two works and that the lyrical theme, content, structure and rhythm are identical. But Judge Martha Picold of the District Court of the Northern District of Illinois disagreed, ruling that it didn't matter whether Future had copied Robinson's song because the material he allegedly borrowed, even if he did so, was not covered by copyright in the first place. Scott: That's right. Citing other examples, including tracks from Biggie, Kanye West and Neil Young. That's an interesting trio, if you think about it. She notes that thematic elements that are frequently present in certain genres of music place them outside of the protections of copyright law. This was the same argument that won the dismissal of the lawsuit against Kanye West over the lyrics what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. In his 2017 hit track Stronger,