Ketubot 32: According to the Amount of One's Wickedness

Talking Talmud - A podcast by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon

A deep dive into a dispute between Ulla and R. Yochanan about not paying and getting lashes, both, for the same event. Plus, a brief discussion of damages in general. Are those damages (5 categories) relevant for all kinds of harm? Also, the mishnayot can be interpreted to mean different cases leading to different punishments, which eases their dispute. Which leads back to one punishment per action - when all the details line up for corporal punishment, as the verses prioritizes things. Note - the value of the damage also makes a difference. As does the presence of witnesses and warning, and so on.

Visit the podcast's native language site